The Neighborhood Hotel New Buffalo, New Buffalo | Explore Room Options, Reviews & Pricing for 2025

Book on our site and save

up to 10%

over Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

18 W Merchant St, New Buffalo, Mi 49117, New Buffalo, Michigan, United States of America, MI 49117

The Neighborhood Hotel New Buffalo, situated steps from New Buffalo Township Library, offers garden views, a terrace, and free private parking. The property features a shared kitchen and select units with balconies.

Modern Room Amenities

Each room at The Neighborhood Hotel New Buffalo includes air conditioning, flat-screen TVs with streaming services, and coffee machines. Double rooms come with private bathrooms equipped with showers, hairdryers, and free toiletries, while select units feature fireplaces.

No Restaurant Service

No dining facilities available on-site.

Outdoor Relaxation Space

The outdoor terrace features garden furniture for guest relaxation. Nearby attractions include Whittaker Woods Golf Course and New Buffalo Railroad Museum.

Marina Area Location

The Neighborhood Hotel positions guests 0.5 miles from Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina and Barney's. South Bend Regional Airport is 34 miles away.

View all

Select your room type

The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

King Suite

Max:

2 persons

400 sq. feet

Bed options:

2 Queen Size Beds

Shower

Coffee machine

room details

Check Prices

Queen Room

Max:

2 persons

305 sq. feet

Bed options:

1 King Size Bed

Shower

Coffee machine

room details

Check Prices

Queen Room Disability Access

Max:

2 persons

360 sq. feet

Bed options:

1 King Size Bed

Shower

Coffee machine

room details

Check Prices

Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

Available transportation options

City Center

New Buffalo700 ft

Airports

South Bend Regional (SBN) 32.5 mi

Midway International (MDW) 64.7 mi

Facilities

The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

Fun for Kids

“During my stay, I was delighted to see the S'mores station available for children. It created a cozy and inviting atmosphere perfect for family bonding. My daughter had such a great time roasting marshmallows, and it truly added to our nice experience.” view full review

Morning Yoga

“I loved that yoga mats were provided for guests. I utilized them for my morning stretches, which made my stay even more rejuvenating. It really showed that the hotel cares about guests' wellness and fitness.” view full review

Comfortable King Room

“I stayed in a King Room that was well-appointed and comfortable. The bed quality was fantastic, ensuring a great night's sleep, and I appreciated having a balcony to relax on during the evenings.” view full review

Homemade Muffins Delight

“Coming back to the hotel after a long day to find fresh homemade muffins waiting for me was such a pleasant surprise! It added a heartfelt touch to the stay and made my evenings so much sweeter.” view full review

General

No smoking on site
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
VIP check-in/ -out
Express check-in/ -out
Concierge desk
Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
Wheelchair access
Security
Fireplace
Smoke detectors
Fire extinguishers

Sports & Fitness

Hiking
Cycling
Golf course
Fishing

Guest Parking

Shared kitchen

Services

Laundry

Dining

Outdoor dining area
Picnic area/ Tables

Business

Meeting/ Banquet facilities

Facilities for people with disabilities

Toilet for disabled
Bathroom for disabled

Spa & Leisure

Beach access
Sun loungers
Sun terrace
Garden area
BBQ facilities
Leisure/ TV room

Room features

Air conditioning
Heating
Patio
Terrace
Garden furniture

Bathroom

Free toiletries

Self-catering

Shared kitchen

Media

Flat-screen TV

Room decor

Carpeted floor

Location

18 W Merchant St, New Buffalo, Mi 49117, New Buffalo, Michigan, United States of America, MI 49117

Map view

18 W Merchant St, New Buffalo, Mi 49117, New Buffalo, Michigan, United States of America, MI 49117

City landmarks

Marina

Oselka's Snug Harbor Marina

2300 ft

Museums

New Buffalo Railroad Museum

4100 ft

Parks

Galien River County Park

1.6 mi

Amusement Park

New Buffalo Township Memorial Park

1.5 mi

Golf Course

Whittaker Woods Golf Course

1.9 mi

Farm

Blueberries Of Indiana

3.0 mi

Nearby

Store

Barney's

1100 ft

Libraries

New Buffalo Township Library

1000 ft

Store

Warner Vineyards Tasting Room

900 ft

Restaurants

Brewster's Italian Cafe

400 ft

11 West Merchant Street

Casey's New Buffalo

900 ft

136 North Whittaker Street

The Stray Dog Bar & Grill

1400 ft

245 North Whittaker Street

Song asian Cusine

1400 ft

301 W Buffalo St

Bentwood Tavern

2800 ft

600 West Water Street

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback from previous guests about their experience.

92%

enjoyed the hotel and would happily return

9.2/10

Perfect

Rooms

8.8

Location

10.0

Service

9.6

Dining

9.0

Jessica

United States of America, March 2025

7.4/10

I had a wonderful stay at The Neighborhood Hotel New Buffalo. The location couldn't be better, allowing for easy walks to local attractions. Although my room was smaller than I anticipated, the beautiful decor created a peaceful atmosphere that I truly enjoyed. I particularly appreciated the excellent service where a staff member went out of her way to offer dining suggestions. However, I did wish the room had a fireplace for extra coziness.

Rooms

9.0

The room was smaller than expected, but it was neat and equipped with every necessary amenity. I loved the balcony.

Service

10.0

The staff were very helpful, especially when it came to dining suggestions. They made my stay much easier.

Location

10.0

The location was perfect for walking to shops and attractions. I enjoyed the convenience it offered.

Dining

9.0

I loved the surprise of homemade muffins at the end of the day, adding a nice touch to my experience.

Facilities

9.0

The hotel provided thoughtful amenities like yoga mats and sunscreen, showing care for guest needs.

Diana

United States of America, February 2025

5.4/10

I had a good stay at The Neighborhood Hotel New Buffalo. The location was fantastic, allowing me to easily walk to nearby attractions. I truly appreciated the cleanliness of my room and found the bed to be incredibly comfortable. However, I did wish there were robes provided for a more luxurious touch.

Rooms

9.0

My King Room with Balcony was clean and equipped with all necessary amenities. The balcony added a lovely private space, though I found the room a bit smaller than I had expected.

Service

10.0

The staff were very helpful, especially one who offered tailored dining suggestions that enhanced my experience during my stay.

Location

10.0

The hotel’s location was perfect. close to shops and other attractions that I wanted to explore.

Dining

9.0

I enjoyed good homemade muffins during my stay, adding a personal touch to the dining experience.

Facilities

9.0

The array of thoughtful amenities, like yoga mats and sunscreen, showed the hotel’s commitment to enhancing guest comfort.

Jennifer

United States of America, February 2025

6.4/10

My stay at The Neighborhood Hotel New Buffalo was pretty great overall, highlighted by the comfy beds and the super clean rooms. However, I did face a bit of a challenge with the luggage situation since my room was on the second floor. The hotel's beautiful decor really set a calming vibe, making my experience enjoyable.

Rooms

9.0

The room was clean and had every amenity anyone would need, though I wish it was a bit bigger. I loved the balcony room I got to enjoy.

Service

10.0

The staff were super helpful, offering great dining suggestions and welcoming touches like homemade muffins, which were a nice surprise after a long day.

Location

10.0

The location was spot on, easy walking distance to all the local shops and attractions, making it super convenient for my stay.

Dining

9.0

I loved the idea of fresh homemade muffins waiting for me at the end of the day, adding a nice personal touch to the dining experience.

Facilities

9.0

The hotel had a variety of thoughtful community amenities like yoga mats and sunscreen, which I really appreciated for a comfortable and enjoyable stay.

Scott

United States of America, January 2025

7.0/10

My stay at The Neighborhood Hotel New Buffalo was quite enjoyable, thanks to the location and the comfy beds. I loved the personal touches, like the homemade muffins, but I did wish the room was a bit larger. Overall, it was a nice balance of comfort and convenience during my trip.

Rooms

8.0

The room was clean and well-equipped, though I found it smaller than expected. I really appreciated the comfortable bed for a restful sleep.

Service

8.0

The staff was very helpful, especially one team member who provided great dining suggestions. However, I would have liked to see more management presence during my stay.

Location

10.0

Perfectly situated, I was able to walk to all the local attractions easily, which made my stay even better.

Dining

9.0

While I didn't eat at the hotel, I enjoyed the choice of local dining options that were conveniently nearby.

Facilities

8.0

The hotel had numerous thoughtful amenities, making my stay comfortable, though I wish there had been robes provided in the room.

Ralph

United States of America, October 2024

5.0/10

I had a wonderful experience at The Neighborhood Hotel New Buffalo. The room was clean and came with all the amenities I needed, and the comfortable bed ensured I got good rest. I especially loved the relaxing decor and the homemade muffins that were a good touch. However, I found the room slightly smaller than I expected, and a fireplace would have been a cozy addition.

Rooms

9.0

The King Room was clean and well-equipped, though a bit smaller than anticipated.

Service

10.0

The staff were genuinely helpful, offering great dining suggestions during my stay.

Location

10.0

Its location was fantastic, just a short walk to all the attractions I wanted to visit.

Dining

9.0

I appreciated the dining recommendations from the staff, enhancing my overall experience.